In this week’s episode of “We Are, Marketing Happy,” the podcast that brings joy to healthcare marketing, our host, CEO, and founder Jenny Bristow, dissects a topic that’s stirring up the digital marketing world alongside Mark Brandes, Hedy & Hopp’s head of all things analytics and decision science. 

This episode sheds light on the mixed feelings surrounding GA4, digging into its challenges and revealing how to harness its full potential. Jenny and Mark go beyond critique, offering practical advice for organizations deeply invested in GA4. Whether you’re grappling with catch-all tracking, seeking clarity on website performance, or looking to beautify your data analysis with Looker Studio dashboards, this episode is packed with actionable solutions. Join us as we transform technical hurdles into opportunities for joy and insight, ensuring your marketing efforts are both happy and effective.

Episode Highlights:

[0:45] – Introduction to GA4’s Mixed Reception: Insights into the digital marketing community’s varied reactions to Google Analytics 4.

[1:20] – The Challenge with GA4: Mark and Jenny discuss the steep learning curve and common frustrations with the new platform.

[2:55] – Embracing Measurement Planning: Highlighting the importance of a well-crafted measurement plan for accurate data analysis in healthcare marketing.

[4:10] – Implementing Dashboards for Better Analytics: How custom dashboards can make data from GA4 more accessible and actionable.

[6:00] – The Future of Healthcare Marketing with GA4: Optimizing Google Analytics 4 for enhanced decision-making in healthcare marketing.

[7:30] – Practical Tips for GA4 Transition: Jenny and Mark offer advice for organizations adapting to Google Analytics 4, focusing on setup and tracking strategies.

Links & Resources

Connect with Jenny

Connect with Mark

Check out more about how Hedy & Hopp can help you do more with your data!

Jenny: [00:00:00] Hi friends. Welcome to today’s episode of “We Are, Marketing Happy,” a healthcare marketing podcast. My name is Jenny Bristow. I am the host, but I am also the CEO and founder of Hedy and Hopp. We’re a full-service fully healthcare marketing agency. We work with healthcare providers, payers, and innovation groups all across the country.

And I am so excited today to have our very own Mark Brandes join us. Mark is the head of all things analytics and decision science here at Hedy & Hopp. So, welcome. 

Mark: Yeah, thanks for having me on Jenny. 

Jenny: So we’re going to talk about a really fun topic today. And that is that a lot of people basically are feeling like Google Analytics 4 sucks.

So what are your thoughts about that?

Mark: They are, and I can’t say I fully disagree. But I do think there are some things that are great about Google Analytics 4, but I also understand where people’s frustrations come from, because I have the same frustration, especially working at an agency [00:01:00] where we have to move around from different clients, and I need quick information out of those tools. And GA4 is not something you can get quick information out of. You have to really put some effort into it, build some things to have the reporting be the same to access some of the data. And so I, I agree.

And I think what we’ve seen is that you can actually, um, create measurement plans that help you really understand what you can measure. And I think that helps really identify what you’re pulling out of the platform that can help. You can also then extend with things like dashboards. So we can talk a little bit about how that would work.

Jenny: Oh, I love it. I love it. And I know we give a little levity to the topic, right? But like, I think the reason why it’s important to address it is there’s a lot of organizations that for one reason or another are tied to using Google Analytics, even with all of the HIPAA and. The patient privacy stuff with a lot of the workarounds, for example, the one that we implement with server-side Google tag manager.

We developed that [00:02:00] program because a lot of people wanted to stick with Google Analytics simply because of the sunk cost of time and energy they’ve already put into setting up the tool and or integrations or dashboards they’ve already set up. So I think on today’s topic. I think we’re going to set aside the fact that yes, there are other tools you can use, right?

The Piwik Pros, the Mixed Panel, like there’s lots of other analytics tools that you could use, but today let’s focus on if you are using Google Analytics for whatever reason, organizationally, if your team has decided you’re sticking with it, then how can you make the most of it? So I’d love for you to start, if an organization is sticking with Google Analytics 4, and they’re just generally frustrated, what’s the first thing that they should do?

Mark: Yeah. And there’s a comfortable nest there, right? Like they’re kind of comfortable. You’ve been using GA and I think that’s one of the things that makes GA more tough is because the interface makes people uncomfortable and you kind of lose that comfort that you had. Right. And so that’s, I think pretty jarring for people.

But yeah, what [00:03:00] we can start to do is for one, when we work with clients, we see a lot of implementations where either their team or an agency or somebody else has come in and they’ve set up what I call just kind of, catch-all tracking. Right? So they’ve gone in and said, we want to track all these links.

Okay, well, let’s track that the link happened and we’ll grab what page it happened on and what page is going to and that’s great until it comes to analytics time, until it comes to the time to the analysis and then things become more difficult. You have to start piecing through all that. You have to pull stuff out.

You have to see was that this link? Was that link? You also have times where it’s not as easy as that. Sometimes it has a JavaScript that comes through. Right? Because you opened up a window instead of opening up a new page. So there’s different things that can break when you do that kind of tracking and that doesn’t really get caught when you kind of just do a throw it all catch it all type of tracking.

So, from our position, it really helps to understand, okay. what are the things that are really important to us on our [00:04:00] website? What’s our website there for? And I think that is a place that we help with having those conversations with really getting down to the heart of, What is this website doing for our business?

And then how can we tie things on the website back to the success of our business? And we do that through a process called measurement planning. So it’s really detailed out and we  define, okay, we want to track when this thing happens on the site. Well, we can help define what does that mean in terms of Google Analytics is this event with this parameter on it.

So we can help define all that. And not only that, but it also helps. Catalog everything and really put it into place. I’ve had so many clients tell us, this is amazing. We’ve never seen this information. We’ve, we know all this, but we’ve never seen it in this format and it helps them understand like, okay, I get what we’re doing now.

I get what we’re tracking. I get where this is coming from. 

Jenny: Yep, absolutely. And I think whenever people think about measurement planning. That sounds like a step that’s a “nice to have”. So I think reframing that conversation internally [00:05:00] where it’s not a nice to have it’s a “must have” if you’re spending money online and need to understand what the ROI is, etc.

So, when you start with the foundation of a strong measurement plan, let’s talk a little bit about how that enables you to make really accurate and detailed, reporting or dashboards. 

Mark: For sure. So a good example is when we moved to GA4 well, in UA, you used to have events that had event category, event action, and event label.

Everybody was so comfortable with that. It made sense, right? You could categorize all this. You could drill down inside your reports. All that’s gone now because everything is an event inside of GA4 and you only have one field for the name. And so you have to either shove all those category, action, and label into that name, which we’ve seen some people do.

We’ve also seen them do, the label as the event and then put category and action as their other parameters to get added onto it. But those are difficult to pull out of the actual interface itself. Trying to drill down into those isn’t the same. When you click on an event, it doesn’t take you to those [00:06:00] next levels.

It takes you to another screen where, yeah, you can look at those levels, but it’s difficult. And you can go into, say, the Explorer reports inside of GA. For you can set up a table there. You can set up a pivot table to help you look at all those different things. But that takes time and effort understanding how the tool works a sense of what pivot tables are, which isn’t the easiest topic for everyone.

And so getting to some of that information, and that’s what I mean by a GA4 feels like it’s terrible, right? Because I can’t get anything out of this. I can’t find the information I’m looking for anymore. And from my perspective. Usually, the information is there. We just haven’t identified what it is, and we haven’t made it easy to bring it out.

And so, yeah, once we have that measurement plan in place, what we can do is really set up a dashboard. And I know sometimes in some circles, dashboards get a bad rap, but I think the way that we approach them is to really have them be an extension of GA4, to bring back some of that reporting field that you had inside of UA, right?

You can drill down into here. You can look at this specific [00:07:00] topic. You can look at your, your month or your date range breakdown. You can see a time chart over that for those specific things. And so that’s something that’s missing at a GA4 currently is your ability to do that. And we can bring that back.

And then you can add it back with adding on something like a Looker Studio dashboard. The great benefit is that Looker Studio is free. So, it’s something you can add on. It’s really the time and effort that takes to set it up and that’s again where we can help with our expertise. We can help you once you have that measurement plan in place, we can help you set up the dashboards. We’ve got somebody on our team who makes beautiful dashboards. Their works of art, in my opinion, but even better. The reason I love that is because it helps you want to come back to the dashboard. It’s not just a spreadsheet looking thing that you come and you just kind of get through.

It looks nice. It’s appealing. And so you want to come back to that dashboard. It’s like, yeah, I do want to go check my dashboard. It’s nice to look at. It’s got my. Yeah. Brand colors. It’s got a good feel to it. And so that’s something that I [00:08:00] find is great because it doesn’t make going through the data at shore.

It makes it kind of a little more happy, a little more fun. 

Jenny: I love it. Our whole focus of our brand is infusing joy. And I think our dashboards definitely do that one thing. Whenever I’m talking to prospective clients and I’m sharing some examples of our dashboards, we see their jaws drop because some examples you can literally drill down by business type.

Or by location. So let’s say you’re a 60-location specialty provider. You can see how one particular location is performing as far as traffic spend campaigns, et cetera. And that’s all because the measurement plan that was done up front made sure all of the tracking and implementation was set up correctly.

So definitely a step not to be missed. 

Mark: Exactly. 

Jenny: Yep. Well, thank you, Mark, for being on always appreciate your perspective and ability to turn something super technical into something that’s easy to digest. So thank you again for being on this week. I love it. And for listeners, thank you so much for tuning in this week.

Be sure to tune in for a future episode of “We Are, Marketing Happy.” Have a great day.

As a healthcare marketing agency, we are often asked about the HIPAA compliance of certain marketing tools. To address this need, we have created a blog series that examines common marketing tools and software to determine whether or not they pose a HIPAA concern.

This week, we’re taking a closer look at Piwik PRO.

What Is Piwik PRO?

Piwik PRO is an advanced, privacy-focused web analytics platform. Designed as an alternative to platforms like Google Analytics, it offers in-depth insights into website traffic while ensuring user data privacy. Prioritizing data ownership and GDPR compliance, Piwik PRO provides both on-premises and cloud hosting options. It caters to businesses wanting granular data without compromising user trust or regulatory requirements.


Significant features:

  • User Privacy: One of Piwik PRO’s major selling points is its focus on data privacy. Their customers have the option to anonymize or redact IP addresses, respect Do Not Track headers, and provide transparent opt-out options for visitors.
  • Heatmaps: These features provide visual insights into where users are clicking, moving, and scrolling on a webpage.
  • Tag Manager: An integrated tag manager helps users easily add and manage various marketing and analytics tags on their website without the need to modify the site’s code directly.
  • Audience Segmentation: Piwik PRO allows for detailed audience segmentation, enabling marketers to analyze specific subsets of their traffic, such as users from a particular location or users who arrived through a specific marketing campaign.
  • Data Ownership: Unlike many other platforms, Piwik PRO ensures that the data collected remains under the website owner’s control. This is a particularly privacy-forward feature of Piwik PRO
  • Multi-site Analytics: Users can manage the analytics for multiple websites within a single Piwik PRO instance.
  • CDP (Customer Data Platform): Piwik’s CDP is available for premium customers. Piwik’s robust CDP allows users to create robust customer profiles and segmented audiences.
  • Consent Management Platform: Piwik PRO boasts an easy-to-use consent management platform that ensures that website visitors can appropriately select their privacy preferences.

Third party integrations: Piwik PRO supports many integrations with other CMS, data visualization and data storage tools, and marketing platforms like Google Ads.

What Data Does Piwik PRO Collect?

Piwik PRO is a first-party data platform that uses a similar framework to Universal Analytics. The biggest difference between Piwik PRO & other analytics platforms is the data ownership. This means that the owner of the website always retains ownership of the data, which is fairly uncommon in similar products. What the platform collects is entirely dependent on the tool’s setup, but the following are almost always collected:

  • Site actions: The primary points of data collection, the events that users take on your site. This could be a button click, a form submission, a video view, or nearly any action you’ve defined on your site.
  • Event properties: The additional information attached to events, such as transaction prices, categories, & other information, which can be defined during setup.
  • Device information: This can include the model of the device the user is using, the operating system, browser.
  • Location data: This includes your approximate location based on your IP address.

Is Piwik PRO HIPAA-Compliant?

Every organization’s definition of HIPAA-compliance is dependent on their legal team’s interpretation of the guidelines set by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. That being said, Piwik PRO falls pretty low on the risk scale because they offer self-storage and are willing to enter into a Business Associate Agreement (BAAs).

Risk Mitigation

Piwik PRO is a data-forward, privacy-focused product, whose risk mitigation options go beyond entering into a BAA. That being said, it is a good idea to ensure you have the following in place in order to catch some common missteps:

  • Ensure that you have a current, valid BAA in place. Schedule regular check-ins to verify that your BAA is still current.
  • Consider any other tools that may be integrated with Piwik PRO – is your configuration sending data to another third party tool? If so, do you have a BAA in place with that vendor? Stay aware of all steps of your data processing, storage, & transmissions and be judicious about integrations that are unnecessary, redundant, or obsolete.
  • Remember that as the website owner, it is your responsibility to own the data process & determine where this data goes. Are you storing it on a third party server? If so, is this server HIPAA-compliant? Each endpoint introduces another possibility for liability and risk.

It’s always important to connect with your legal team to determine how best to move forward. Listen to our HIPAA & FTC 101 podcast for more information about changes for healthcare companies.

Not sure how to get started?

Hedy & Hopp has already engaged multiple healthcare clients to perform an audit and risk assessment that both marketing and legal teams can use to make the best decisions for their business. If you’re looking to make sure your marketing practices are compliant, let’s talk – we’d love to help!

As a healthcare marketing agency, we are often asked about the HIPAA compliance of certain marketing tools. To address this need, we have created a blog series that examines common marketing tools and software to determine whether or not they pose a HIPAA concern.

This week, we’re taking a closer look at Mixpanel.

What Is Mixpanel?

Mixpanel is a popular analytics platform, similar to Google Analytics. It’s widely used by marketers who want an alternative to Google Analytics, an upgrade to GA’s free version without taking the steep price hike to Analytics 360, as well as product teams wanting to improve their users’ experience. Mixpanel can also offer a more customized analytics or reporting system without going “around the system” in the way you sometimes need to in Google Analytics (Google Analytics was to provide very basic insights out of the box for just about any user who was willing to complete a simple setup guide). 

Mixpanel, however, is not intended for beginners, and instead focuses on marketers & product team members who are looking for a highly customizable product that exists outside of the Google ecosystem. Mixpanel’s popularity has grown further since the release of Mixpanel Marketing Analytics.

Healthcare marketers use Mixpanel to do the following:

  • Analyze patient journeys: Mixpanel can be used to understand the journeys that patients take when seeking care, from initial research to booking appointments. 
  • Segmentation: Marketers can divide audiences into specific segments based on behavior, demographics, pages viewed, or any other number of trackable metrics.
  • A/B testing: Mixpanel allows for robust testing features, allowing marketers to test campaigns, webpages, and more in order to boost conversion rates.
  • Retention: Mixpanel can be used to measure user retention, which can help teams determine how sticky their content is.
  • Flexible and complex attribution: Mixpanel allows for highly customized attribution models, which can be tailored to specific user journeys.

What Data Does Mixpanel Collect?

Mixpanel is a first-party data platform that, much like GA4, operates on an event-based framework. What the platform collects is entirely dependent on the tool’s setup, but the following are almost always collected:

  • Site actions: The primary points of data collection, site actions are the events that users take on your website. This could be a button click, a form submission, a video view, or nearly any action you’ve defined on your site.
  • Event properties: The additional information attached to events, such as transaction prices, categories, & other information, which can be defined during setup.
  • Device information: This can include the model of the device the user is using, the operating system, browser.
  • Location data: This includes your approximate location based on your IP address.

Is Mixpanel HIPAA-Compliant?

Every organization’s definition of HIPAA-compliance is dependent on their legal team’s interpretation of the guidelines set by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. That being said, Mixpanel falls fairly low on the risk scale, largely because Mixpanel is willing to enter into Business Associate Agreements (BAAs) with its customers.

Risk Mitigation

Mixpanel is a data-forward, privacy-focused product, whose risk mitigation options go beyond entering into a BAA. Mixpanel is built on Google Cloud Platform, which is subjected to regular, independent verification of security, privacy, & compliance controls against HIPAA. That being said, it is a good idea to ensure you have the following in place in order to catch some common missteps:

  • Ensure that you have a current, valid BAA in place. Schedule regular check-ins to verify that your BAA is still current.
  • Consider any other tools that may be integrated with Mixpanel – is your configuration sending data to another third party tool? If so, do you have a BAA in place with that vendor? Stay aware of all steps of your data processing, storage, and transmissions, and be judicious about integrations that are unnecessary, redundant, or obsolete.

It’s always important to connect with your legal team to determine how best to move forward. Listen to our HIPAA & FTC 101 podcast for more information about changes for healthcare companies.

Not sure how to get started?

Hedy & Hopp has already engaged multiple healthcare clients to perform an audit and risk assessment that both marketing and legal teams can use to make the best decisions for their business. If you’re looking to make sure your marketing practices are compliant, let’s talk – we’d love to help!

As a healthcare marketing agency, we get a lot of questions about whether or not certain tools are HIPAA-compliant. That’s why we at Hedy & Hopp decided to create a blog series that specifically dives into common marketing tools and software in order to determine whether or not it poses a HIPAA concern.

 

This week, we’re taking a closer look at Google Analytics (GA4).

What Is Google Analytics?

GA4 is the latest version of Google Analytics, the most popular analytics tool in the world. It is also the biggest change to the tool since its original release in 2005. For the first time ever, Google Analytics will not be backwards compatible with previous versions of the platform’s tags. GA4 requires a complete reinstallation of tracking tags, which has many users reevaluating their tracking platforms. Paired with OCR’s recent bulletin which identified IP addresses as PHI, this shift in the ecosystem has made the question of how Google Analytics fits in HIPAA-compliance a hot topic for healthcare marketers

What Data Does Google Analytics Collect?

Google Analytics, unsurprisingly, collects a lot of data about your user:

  • User ID: This is a unique identifier that is assigned to each user. GA4 uses this ID to track users across multiple sessions and devices.
  • User properties: These are additional pieces of information about users, such as their age, gender, location, and interests.
  • Events: These are actions that users take on your website or app. For example, an event could be a pageview, a download, or a purchase. These events need to be setup by the owner .
  • Sessions: A session is a group of interactions that a user takes on your website or app within a certain period of time.
  • Dimensions: These are the different attributes of your data, such as the date, time, and page URL.
  • Metrics: These are the measurements of your data, such as the number of users, sessions, and events.

Is Google Analytics HIPAA-Compliant?

Google Analytics 4 has made a lot of improvements that make it easier for companies to utilize stronger data privacy standards and move further into the age of cookieless tracking. These changes allow the tool to be used more in line with GDPR, CCPA, & other privacy policies. Despite these changes, however, Google Analytics is not HIPAA-compliant, as it still receives and stores PII/PHI, including device IDs, browser information, and location data, and does not offer a BAA. Google even explicitly states that “Google makes no representations that Google Analytics satisfies HIPAA requirements” and instructs users to refrain from exposing the software from any information that could be considered PII/PHI.

Risk Mitigation

There are several ways to make Google Analytics safer with strong data privacy standards. These are available in the Privacy Controls section of your Google Analytics settings. While enabling these settings will not satisfy HIPAA guidelines, it could help safeguard some user data while you determine a path forward (see our blog, Auditing your marketing plan for HIPAA compliance)

  • Data collection: You can disable the collection of certain types of data in Google Analytics, such as location data, device information, and user-agent strings.
  • Data sharing: You can control how your data is shared with other Google products and services, including Google Ads & YouTube.
  • Consent mode: You can enable consent mode, which allows you to collect data from users who have given their consent.
  • Data retention: You can control how long your data is retained by Google Analytics.
  • User-level data access and portability: You can grant users access to their own data in Google Analytics.

 

PRO TIP: Server-side tagging is a data tracking method that can help organizations protect user data. While it requires a well thought out digital infrastructure, it can give organizations more control over their data and help them comply with privacy regulations while still using Google Analytics.

Where do you go from here?

Hedy & Hopp’s Analytics experts can help by auditing your Google Analytics account for you, so reach out if your team is struggling with how to approach what can be quite an undertaking!

We have already engaged multiple healthcare clients to perform an audit and risk assessment that both marketing and legal teams can use to make the best decisions for their business. Give us a call – we’d love to help!